She Went On Two Dates With The Alleged Gilgo Beach Serial Killer

Close up of young couple toasting with glasses of red wine at restaurant
InsideCreativeHouse - stock.adobe.com - illustrative purposes only, not the actual people

When TikToker Ivy Sunderji (@thehappypsychic) was 22 years old, she went on a date with an alleged serial killer.

It was 2007, and she had just graduated from college. She lived in New York and met a man on a dating site. His name was Andrew, and he was incredibly creepy.

For their first date, they went to see the movie No Country for Old Men. He seemed way too into the killing scenes. His face was turning bright red, and he just had this super excited, erratic energy about him.

After that, she didn’t want to go on another date with him, but she didn’t trust her own judgment or instincts and agreed to go on a second date.

They ended up going out to dinner, and he started telling her about how his brother, who lived in South Carolina, liked to go hunting.

Once Ivy revealed that she was a vegetarian, he claimed that they only shot at clay pigeons. He also said a bunch of misogynistic things about a book she had written in college and then tried to play footsie with her under the table.

It was unsettling because, come to find out, he was actually old enough to be her dad.

As dinner went on, he started to become more and more creepy and controlling. She got this really bad feeling, so she finally told him that she needed to go home.

He followed her out of the restaurant and put on a pair of brown leather driving gloves, even though the weather was not cold enough to need gloves.

Close up of young couple toasting with glasses of red wine at restaurant
InsideCreativeHouse – stock.adobe.com – illustrative purposes only, not the actual people

Sign up for Chip Chick’s newsletter and get stories like this delivered to your inbox.

Then, he pulled out a wad of cash and waved it at her. He offered to give her a ride home so she wouldn’t have to take the subway.

Her body and mind were screaming at her to get away from this man. She ran to the nearest subway station and got on the train. Once she arrived home, she deleted his phone number.

A few years ago, she was watching the news and saw that he had been arrested for being the Gilgo Beach serial killer.

She is glad that she never got into his car because she is sure that she would’ve gone missing.

@thehappypsychic

I literally went on a date with a serial killer! Well, alleged. Accused. People deserve the presumption of innocence but even his family is saying they think he did it… And I met this man. T#Thisas back in 2007. I left dinner with him thinking I might get murdered if I didn’t run away. I’m about to watch the Peacock documentary about him — The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets ? #truecrime #onlinedating

? original sound – Ivy Sunderji
Emily  Chan is a writer who covers lifestyle and news content. She graduated from Michigan State University with a ... More about Emily Chan

More About: