He Did Not Recognize His Sister-In-Law When He Saw Her Without Any Makeup On And Figured She Was A Stranger Who Broke Into Their House

New Africa - stock.adobe.com - illustrative purpose only, not the actual person
New Africa - stock.adobe.com - illustrative purpose only, not the actual person

A 33-year-old guy has spent the last 4 years married to his 32-year-old wife Kate, but before they tied the knot, they dated for an entire decade.

He knows Kate’s family quite well, especially her older sister named Emily. Kate and Emily are super close, and Emily comes to stay with them multiple times a month.

Emily also adores their kids and will take them to do fun things. They also do a lot all together, such as hiking or taking vacations.

He and Kate have never once asked Emily to step in to babysit their children since they hire a nanny to do that, and also, his mom pitches in. This is just something Emily enjoys doing.

“Now Emily is a lot into makeup,” he explained. “In fact, I have never seen her without heavy makeup.”

“Even when she stays over, she comes out from her room with a full face on and wears waterproof makeup to the swimming pool or to the beach. From what Kate told me, she has been like this since Emily was 13.”

This weekend, Emily was staying with them, and their daughter ended up sneaking right into Emily’s room and taking her makeup.

Their daughter then hid Emily’s makeup somewhere in the house, and this happened really early on in the day.

“When I woke up I bumped into Emily in the hallway while she was looking for her makeup and did not recognize her at all,” he said.

New Africa – stock.adobe.com – illustrative purpose only, not the actual person

Sign up for Chip Chick’s newsletter and get stories like this delivered to your inbox.

“She looked completely different from what I’m used to and looked like a middle-aged woman. I nearly called the police as I thought someone broke into our house, but Kate stopped me.”

“However, Emily already heard me saying “who the hell are you” and is aware I have not recognized her.”

He did say sorry to Emily, and he did let her know why he did not recognize her. He ended up mentioning to Emily that she just looks like a completely different person without her makeup on, so that’s why he couldn’t tell that it was her that morning.

When he said that, Emily and Kate called him a jerk. He honestly can’t see how that was mean of him when he was just telling the truth.

Since then, Emily and Kate kept on being upset with him. Meanwhile, Emily and Kate’s parents agree with him, so he’s curious if he’s really wrong.

Do you think it was rude of him to tell Emily to her face that he couldn’t recognize her without her makeup on?

You can read the original post on Reddit here.

If true crime defines your free time, this is for you: join Chip Chick’s True Crime Tribe.

37 Years Ago, This College Girl Was Found With Her Throat Slashed In A Cornfield While On A Trip To Meet Up With A Guy She Met On Spring Break

New Research Finds Why Narcissists Are More Likely To Believe In Conspiracy Theories

Her Dad And Brother Kept Making Jokes About It Being “That Time Of The Month,” So She Got Some Sweet Revenge

His Youngest Son Made Fun Of His Older Son’s First Car, So He Called Him Spoiled And Now The Whole Family Is Mad At Him

Her Boyfriend’s Sister Keeps Racking Up Bills On Their Credit Card, So She Froze The Account, And Now Her Boyfriend Is Furious

She Received A “Wellness Check” From Her Local Book Store After Ordering Two Dark Novels

More About: