She Had A Creepy First Date Experience With A Man Who Already Knew The Questions He Was Asking, And Now She Believes You Should Check Social Media Before Attending A Date

alfa27- Stock.Adobe.com, illustrative purposes only, not the actual people
alfa27- Stock.Adobe.com, illustrative purposes only, not the actual people

Some people have a strict rule that they don’t stalk someone’s social media before going on a first date with them because they believe it would prevent you from getting a proper first impression. Plus, many of us know that how someone appears on social media isn’t always how they appear in person.

But one woman now firmly believes you should always check a guy’s social media before going on a first date after a first date horror story she experienced.

Madi (@immadeleine) is a fashion photographer living in New York City who took to TikTok to tell her followers about a weird and creepy dating experience she had.

Madi was out with friends one night when she noticed a cute guy staring at her. Eventually, he approached her and asked if she wanted to get dinner with him.

She said yes and got his information to plan the date, but didn’t look up his social media profiles before their date. 

Madi and the guy went to dinner together, and things were going well. Then, he started asking her a bunch of ‘get to know you’ questions. He asked her what she does for work, asked to see some of her photographs, etc.

But then, things got a little strange.

“As dinner went on, he started to ask me more questions where I felt like he already knew the answer to [them],” says Madi in her video.

Madi figured her date might have looked up her social media pages and had a quick look before their date, so she carried on with the rest of the night. 

alfa27- Stock.Adobe.com, illustrative purposes only, not the actual people

Later that evening, while at home, she was on FaceTime with a friend to fill her in on the date when she decided to finally look this guy up on social media, starting with Instagram.

“I find his Instagram, and as soon as I see the username, my stomach sinks,” recalls Madi.

She knew she had seen that username before.

As it turns out, this guy had been sending her random messages for the past five years online before he met her in person. Madi estimated he sent around 45 unsolicited messages to her. He would reply to her Instagram stories, message her asking about her friends and work, etc. 

Although this Instagram stalker acted like he was asking Madi genuine first-date questions about her life, he definitely knew the answers already.

“I don’t know why he couldn’t just tell me that he was following me before, but I got super creeped out,” says Madi.

How would you feel if you were in Madi’s position?

If true crime defines your free time, this is for you: join Chip Chick’s True Crime Tribe

In March, This 26-Year-Old From Florida Vanished After Getting Into A Pickup Truck With Two Men She Did Not Know 

She Worked Tirelessly In The Big Apple Despite Being Faced With Discrimination, And She Went On To Become America’s Very First Major Prima Ballerina

She’s Explaining Why She Always Waters Her Plants In The Shower, And It Makes A Lot Of Sense

His Wife Says He Humiliated Her After He Accidentally Made Her Pay For Her Own Mother’s Day Breakfast

She Found Out Her Boyfriend Went On Bumble After A Minor Misunderstanding, So She Broke Up With Him, And Now She’s Wondering If She Did The Right Thing

She’s A Young Mom Of 12, And She’s Answering Questions Such As Are People Rude To Her When She Takes All Of Her Kids Out In Public, And Does Giving Birth Ever Get Easier?

Sign up for Chip Chick’s newsletter and get stories like this delivered to your inbox.

More About: