9 People Discuss The Creepiest Unsolved Mysteries That They Have Ever Heard Of
Spend enough time on the internet, and you’ll come to find that are plenty of mysteries across the world that have yet to be solved.
Below, these 9 people discuss the creepiest unsolved mysteries that they have ever heard of. Hopefully, these mysteries will finally be solved soon.
Mary Shotwell Little
“Mary Shotwell Little has always kept me up at night. Went missing after shopping at Lenox Mall in Atlanta in 1965.”
“She was a newlywed so she was called the Missing Bride. She was reported missing by coworkers the next morning but her car was no longer in the Lenox parking lot.”
“Her husband was out of town and when he returned and went to Lenox to look for her, her car was now there.”
“The car had her groceries, blood spots, and a folded pair of women’s underwear on the console.”
“Lots of weird details in this case like the car being returned in daylight, her credit card being used and her being spotted in NC under duress and with two men. Her body has never been found and the case is still unsolved.”
Prostock-studio – stock.adobe.com
Sign up for Chip Chick’s newsletter and get stories like this delivered to your inbox.
Leah Croucher
“Happened in 2019 in my town. A few days after Valentine’s Day a 19-year-old named Leah Croucher mysteriously disappears on her way to work. On her way to work, there is a lake that she has to walk around.”
“There was CCTV footage on 2 spots on the footpath around the lake. She is seen walking on the first camera but there is a short space between the second camera (around 2 minutes) but she never appears on the second camera meaning she went missing in that short space between the 2 cameras.”
“She was a black belt in karate and her dad is a karate instructor meaning she probably could’ve fought off an attacker. A woman sees her just before she disappears crying with her AirPods in.”
“Divers search the lake multiple times but find no body. A few months later a woman claims she saw a hoodie that matched the one Leah was wearing when she disappeared hanging from a tree in the forest next to the lake but is no longer there. The family reveals she was having a relationship with a man in his 30s which they describe as X.”
“He was a married man I think who was having an affair with her. Her family tells her to end the relationship because he’s married and the relationship will not go far.”
“Just before Valentine’s Day, Leah’s dad drops her off at a premier (big hotel chain in England) where she was going to stay with her friends where they were going to drink alcohol and do their nails and gossip and just be normal teenage girls.”
“Friends say that they never did that. Later on, they find out that Leah walked off to a not as good hotel and pays for a room which she is suspected to have stayed in with X. No video footage proof as it’s been too long and the hotel deleted all footage from that time.”
“X is interrogated and has an alibi for the time she disappeared and deemed innocent. All Leah’s bank accounts have remained untouched and her phone turned off. Just before Leah’s 20th birthday, her brother commits suicide because he can’t deal with not knowing what happened to her.”
“Then covid hit and everyone forgot about her. Nowadays if you go through my town you will see missing posters from 2 years ago and a 5 thousand pound reward for information billboard on the motorway or spray paint on a bus stop saying find Leah.”
Cindy Hack
“The story of Cindy Hack. Had a stalker for 7 years. Reported many, many occurrences of the stalker to the police So many, in fact, they eventually stopped believing her, as they never once saw any stalker activity.”
“The ordeal put her through hell, and made her into an extremely anxious, paranoid person. She eventually turned up dead at some random abandoned house, bound and overdosed. People are split. Some think she did it herself, others think she did have a stalker.”
The Disappearance Of The Sodder Children
“In the 1940s it was Christmas Eve and the Sodder family was getting ready for bed. The mother allowed the youngest children to stay up late, as long as they were supervised by the eldest daughter.”
“A while later there was a phone call and the mother went to go answer, but when she picked up it was just a woman’s laughter. After answering she went to go check on the kid’s but none of them were down there except the eldest daughter that was fast asleep on the couch.”
“The youngest children had gone to bed… so it appeared. The blinds were not shut, the door was not locked. These were regular things the kids had to do, and the mother assumed that they had just forgot.”
“She did the chores and then went to sleep. A bit later she was awoken by what seemed to be a rubber ball bouncing on the roof. She ignored it and then went back to sleep. A bit later she woke up again and there was a huge fire that had started and was beginning to engulf the house, the mother woke the father who woke the children and one of the children was in charge of waking up the kids sleeping in the attic.”
“The entire first floor was engulfed and the boy went up and yelled for the kids sleeping in the attic to come down, he ran after yelling and got out of the house, but the kids never followed. After the entire house was engulfed they began sobbing, realizing the kids were most likely dead.”
“The court determined that the fire was caused by faulty electrical boxes. But the most chilling detail in the story, is that no bones were found of the kids. And something that could be even worse, is that in the bushes, behind their house, they found a Pineapple grenade.”
Mary Morris & Mary Morris
“The two Mary Morris murders. They occurred near Houston Texas within days of each other. Police believe they are connected but it is a big mystery as to who did it. It is still unsolved. This happened in the early 2000s.”
The John Does In The Mountains
“This one isn’t well known, but I found it last night while killing time (no pun intended). On March 28th, 1979 hikers discovered a decomposed body in a rugged, mountainous area.”
“The remains were determined to belong to a young white man between the ages of 16-22. He had been decapitated. While searching for his head, police found another decapitated body and a severed head that did not belong to either of the two victims.”
“So, 2 headless bodies and a severed head were found. None of the three victims were ever identified and they remain John Does to this day. There’s something really creepy about finding the decapitated remains of 3 young men and, not only never identifying the killer, but never identifying the victims themselves. You’d think, out of the 3 victims, at least one person who knows any of them would come forward or report them missing.”
The Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murders
“The Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murders in 1972-73. I grew up in the area but didn’t hear anything about it until a couple of years ago. Seven girls and women were murdered and dumped along rural roads in Sonoma County.”
“The case is often overshadowed by the Golden State Killer and Zodiac Killer. Who murdered these girls in sleepy Sonoma County remains a mystery to this day.”
The Neighbor
“When I was a little kid, the next-door neighbor’s wife disappeared and was later found dead. My sister and I, and our neighborhood friends would snoop on his property all the time.”
“Well, while he was at work one day, we were digging behind a shed behind his house for whatever reason (we were kids, so who knows what we were thinking) and we legit dug up a duffel bag that had bloody butcher knives, ropes, leather gloves, and some clothing that looked as though there was a struggle based on tears and the dirt and grime.”
“This man came home and caught us, took the duffel with all of the items, and told us to stop snooping on his property. We were never able to show our parents. My sister and I swear that man killed his wife. But he has since died, and we will never know.”
Holiday In Thailand
“A story my father told me about his childhood friend. He took his wife and daughter (5 at that time) to Thailand for holidays.”
“They traveled in a group of like 10. One day they were on a local market, shopping for spices, etc. His daughter was with the mother, but other adults from the group were also nearby. She checked some goods on a stand and when she turned back, the girl was nowhere to be seen.”
“They immediately called the police, but after 2 days of search they were told that after such a long time the chance they find her is really low and that they should prepare for the worst.”
“The wife has returned home and lost her senses out of grief – was placed in a mental hospital. The father has stayed behind and searched for a couple more months (!) until he gave up. I don’t know how they are doing at the moment, as my father has lost contact with the guy.”
“This happened like 8 years ago and she was never found. I am 26 atm and my stomach still feels heavy when I think what might have happened to her.”
More About:Freaky
Read This Next
