In June 2016, the body of 30-year-old Alyssa Romine-Olson was found in a pond at the Riparian Preserve in Gilbert, Arizona. She was last seen alive on June 8, 2016, at 9 p.m. A decade later, her family is still no closer to knowing what happened to her.

Alyssa had just returned to her parents' home in Gilbert following her separation from her husband, Braden Taft Olson. The couple lived in the state of Washington. Every day, she would go to the Riparian Preserve, sit by the pond, pray, journal, and meditate.

On the morning of June 9, she left for the preserve before her parents woke up. However, she never returned home. When night fell, her father went out to search for her. Alyssa's van was still there, but she was nowhere to be seen.

The family called the police at 11:19 p.m. to report her missing, and a search began. A helicopter with infrared cameras scanned the area from overhead while bloodhounds tracked her scent on foot.

The next day, her unclothed body was found floating face down in one of the seven ponds on the preserve. The pond was in an area with thick vegetation that hid it from view from the main trails. She was still wearing her rings and necklaces.

Alyssa had no known medical issues or a history of mental illness or alcohol/drug abuse. No water was found in her lungs, which meant she hadn't actually drowned. Her family believes her death is suspicious.

Investigators collected DNA from her body, but didn't find much. Since her body had been in the water for some time and was exposed to the hot summer temperatures of Arizona, her body may have experienced advanced decomposition. The pond was also drained, but nothing was found. The official cause of her death is undetermined.

In an interview with the Gilbert Sun News in September 2023, Alyssa's parents claimed that her husband, Braden, had forbidden them and anyone else in their family from speaking about Alyssa at her funeral.

They also claimed that some members of the Sun Valley Community Church, who were allowed to speak, stated that Alyssa was "better off dead than with her family." Alyssa's family did not know these people.

Green lily pads and aquatic plants floating on dark pond waternagelsphoto - stock.adobe.com - illustrative purposes only - pictured above are lily pads in a dark pond

Alyssa's sister, Chelsea, said that an unidentified Asian male followed the family home from a visit to the Riparian Preserve about four months after Alyssa's death. She thinks that someone from the church could have killed Alyssa.

Another suspect was someone who hung out at the library near the preserve and at the preserve itself. Police searched his bag and discovered latex gloves, religious writings and a woman's hair tie.

Braden was interviewed by the police three times. The first time was when he returned to Arizona after Alyssa's body was found, then twice in Washington, where he was living.

Braden said that the day before Alyssa went missing, they talked for two hours. He didn't like being away from her, but they couldn't be together because he had thoughts of being unfaithful to her.

He told police that he was viewing adult content and had lustful feelings toward other women. Police found evidence of this on his phone. He also wanted to drink and smoke and get a job and a house. Apparently, Alyssa did not approve of that.

According to police, Braden believed that demons were involved in Alyssa's death. He was able to draw a detailed map of where her remains were discovered, even though the exact location had never been publicly disclosed.

He claimed that the map came from media footage, but detectives could not find any such footage.

To this day, Alyssa's family believes she was murdered. They haven't heard any updates from the police in years and hope that more progress is made in the near future.

Anyone with information about the case is urged to contact the Gilbert Police at 480-503-6500.

If true crime defines your free time, this is for you: join Chip Chick’s True Crime Tribe